National Honors
| Lt. Raymond Enners Memorial Award |
| Nation's Outstanding Player |
| Doug Schreiber |
1973 |
| Frank Urso |
1975 |
| Brian Dougherty |
1995 |
| Jack Turnbull Memorial Award |
| Nation's Outstanding Attackman |
| C. Rennie Smith |
1954 |
| Richard Corrigan |
1958 |
| Ray Altman |
1963 |
| Jack Heim |
1967 |
| John Kaestner |
1972 |
| Bob Boneillo |
1979 |
| Mark Douglas |
1991 |
| Joe Walters |
2006 |
| Lt. Don MacLaughlin Memorial Award |
| Nation's Outstanding Midfielder |
| Doug Schreiber |
1973 |
| Frank Urso |
1974, 1976 |
| Doug Radebaugh |
1975 |
| Schmeisser Memorial Cup |
| Nation's Outstanding Defenseman |
| Robert Fetters |
1946 |
| William Hubbell |
1952 |
| John Simmons |
1956 |
| Mike Thearle |
1973 |
| Mike Farrell |
1976 |
| Brian Burlace |
1992 |
| Dan Radebaugh |
1995 |
| Michael Howley |
2003 |
| Lee Zink |
2004 |
| C.M. Kelly, Jr. Memorial Cup |
| Nation's Outstanding Goalie |
| William Larash |
1952 |
| James Kappler |
1955, 1956, 1957 |
| John Schofield |
1965 |
| Brian Dougherty |
1995, 1996 |
| North-South Outstanding Player |
| Brian Dougherty |
1996 |
| USILA Coach of the Year |
| John Faber |
1959 |
| Bud Beardmore |
1973 |
| Dick Edell |
1995 |
| USILA Howdy Myers Award |
| Man of the Year |
|
| John F. Kelly |
1959 |
| NCAA Tournament 25th Anniversary Team |
| Frank Urso |
1976 |
| W. H. Brine Memorial Award |
| Outstanding Player in NCAA Championship |
| Brian Dougherty |
1995 |
| NCAA All-Tournament |
| Brian Dougherty |
1995 |
| Dan Radebaugh |
1995 |
| Matt Hahn |
1995 |
| Peter Hilgartner |
1995 |
| Rob Chomo |
1995 |
| Matt Hahn |
1997 |
| Andrew Whipple |
1997 |
| Scott Hochstadt |
1998 |
| Brian Haggerty |
1998 |
| Mike Bonanni |
1998 |
| Michael Howley |
2003 |
| Joe Walters |
2005 |
| Started in 1995 |
|
