All-Americans
| Player |
Position (Years) |
Award |
| Tom Brown |
Outfield (1962) |
ABCA - 1st Team |
| Will Frazier |
Outfield (2002) |
CB - Freshman Team |
| Derek Hacopian |
Outfield (1992) |
ABCA - 1st Team |
| |
|
BA- 2nd Team |
| |
|
CB - 1st Team |
| John Hetrick |
Outfield (1967) |
ABCA - 2nd Team |
| |
|
TSN - 1st Team |
| Bob Grossman |
Pitcher (1972) |
AACBC - 1st Team |
| Gene Hiser |
Outfield (1970) |
ABCA - 1st Team |
| |
|
TSN - 1st Team |
| Jason Maxey |
Catcher (2002) |
CB - Freshman Team |
| John McCurdy |
Infield (2002) |
NCBWA - 1st Team |
| |
|
BA- 2nd Team |
| |
|
ABCA - 3rd Team |
| Jim Pitt |
Outfield (1964) |
ABCA - 2nd Team |
| Dave Suave |
2nd Base (1971) |
ABCA - 3rd Team |
|
| Key: AACBC (American Association of College Baseball Coaches), ABCA (American Baseball Coaches Association), BA (Baseball America), CB (Collegiate Baseball), NCBWA (National Collegiate Baseball Writers Assoc.) TSN (The Sporting News) |
|
|
