All-Americans
1923 | 1924 | 1925 | 1926 | 1927 | 1928 | 1929
1930 | 1931 | 1932 | 1933 | 1934 | 1935 | 1936 | 1937 | 1938 | 1939
1940 | 1941 | 1942 | 1943 | 1946 | 1947 | 1948 | 1949
1950 | 1951 | 1952 | 1953 | 1954 | 1955 | 1956 | 1957 | 1958 | 1959
1960 | 1961 | 1962 | 1963 | 1964 | 1965 | 1966 | 1967 | 1968 | 1969
1970 | 1971 | 1972 | 1973 | 1974 | 1975 | 1976 | 1977 | 1978 | 1979
1980 | 1981 | 1982 | 1983 | 1984 | 1985 | 1986 | 1987 | 1988 | 1989
1990 | 1991 | 1992 | 1993 | 1994 | 1995 | 1996 | 1997 | 1998 | 1999
2000 | 2001 | 2002 | 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009
2010 | 2011 | 2012
| 1923 | Ivan Marty | Point | 1st |
| Cecil Branner | Out Home | 2nd | |
| Charles Brewer | Defense | 3rd | |
| Joseph Burger | CoverPoint | HM | |
| Ralph Heidelbach | Attack | HM | |
| 1924 | Ivan Marty | CoverPoint | 1st |
| Gomer Lewis | Out Home | 1st | |
| 1925 | John Hough | Defense | 1st |
| Gomer Lewis | Out Home | 1st | |
| Arthur Sleasman | Goal | 2nd | |
| Tilgman Marden | In Home | 2nd | |
| Joseph Burger | CoverPoint | 3rd | |
| Ed Smith | Center | HM | |
| 1926 | Russell Allen | Defense | 1st |
| William Beatty | In Home | 2nd | |
| Kinsley McDonald | Defense | 2nd | |
| Lionel Ensor | CenterField | HM | |
| John Faber | Attack | HM | |
| 1927 | Samuel Crosswaite | Attack | 1st |
| Arthur Boyd | Attack | 2nd | |
| Alex Muzzy | Defense | 3rd | |
| John Faber | Out Home | 3rd | |
| Fred Linkous | Attack | HM | |
| 1928 | Wilbur Street | Goal | 1st |
| Frederick Linkous | In Home | 1st | |
| Slater Davidson | Center | HM | |
| 1929 | Emmett Loane | Defense | 1st |
| William Evans | In Home | 1st | |
| William Beck | Center | HM | |
| William Holloway | Attack | HM | |
| Albert Heagy | Defense | HM | |
| 1930 | James Kelly | Goal | 1st |
| William Evans | Home | 1st | |
| Albert Heagy | Defense | 1st | |
| Charles Dodson | CoverPoint | 2nd | |
| William Beck | Center | 2nd | |
| Jack Norris | Defense | HM | |
| 1931 | Joe Deckman | Point | 1st |
| Gordon Pugh | Center | 1st | |
| Ed Ronkin | Home | 1st | |
| Charles May | Defense | 2nd | |
| James Lee | Attack | 2nd | |
| Fred Invernezzi | Goal | HM | |
| Vincent Colosimo | Attack | HM | |
| Fred Stieber | Attack | HM | |
| 1932 | Gordon Pugh | Center | 1st |
| Ed Ronkin | Home | 1st | |
| Morris Nicholson | Point | 1st | |
| Jack Norris | Defense | 1st | |
| 1933 | Norwood Sothoron | Defense | 1st |
| Gordon Pugh | Center | 1st | |
| Gerald Snyder | Point | 2nd | |
| Carl Pfau | Goal | HM | |
| George Hockensmith | Attack | HM | |
| 1934 | Samuel Silber | CoverPoint | 1st |
| Norwood Sothoron | Defense | 1st | |
| 1935 | Samuel Silber | CoverPoint | 1st |
| Charles Ellinger | In Home | 1st | |
| Leonard Rombro | Defense | 1st | |
| Ramsay Thomas | Attack | 1st | |
| John Christhilf | Out Home | HM | |
| 1936 | John Kelly | Goal | 1st |
| Louis Ennis | Point | 1st | |
| Charles Ellinger | Out Home | 1st | |
| Alton Rabbit | Defense | 1st | |
| Herbert Brill | Attack | 1st | |
| John Christhilf | Out Home | 1st | |
| Parker Lindsay | Center | HM | |
| 1937 | John Kelly | Goal | 1st |
| Charles Ellinger | Out Home | 1st | |
| Robert Neilson | In Home | 1st | |
| John Page | Point | HM | |
| James Meade | Defense | HM | |
| 1938 | Parker Lindsay | Attack | 1st |
| Robert Neilson | In Home | 1st | |
| Milton Mulitz | Point | 2nd | |
| George Watson | Attack | 2nd | |
| 1939 | Milton Mulitz | Point | 1st |
| James Meade | Defense | 1st | |
| Fredic Hewitt | Attack | 3rd | |
| 1940 | Milton Mulitz | CoverPoint | 1st |
| Oscar Nevares | Out Home | 1st | |
| William Bond | Attack | 2nd | |
| Leo Muller | Point | 3rd | |
| William Cole | Center | 3rd | |
| 1941 | Leo Muller | Point | 1st |
| Jordon Sexton | Attack | 2nd | |
| Albert Slesinger | Out Home | 2nd | |
| 1942 | William McGregor | Defense | 2nd |
| Ramon Grelecki | In Home | 2nd | |
| James Forbes | Goal | 3rd | |
| 1943 | Jack Ditmar | CoverPoint | 1st |
| John Hoyert | Attack | 1st | |
| Robert Stockbridge | In Home | 2nd | |
| Arthur Lundvall | Center | 3rd | |
| Lloyd Mallonee | Attack | 3rd | |
| 1946 | Robert Fetters | Point | 1st |
| Thomas Hoffecker | Goal | 2nd | |
| 1947 | Jiles Freeman | Out Home | 2nd |
| John Ruppersberger | CenterPoint | 2nd | |
| Thomas Hoffecker | Goal | 3rd | |
| Ray Grelecki | HM | ||
| 1948 | Thomas Hoffecker | Goal | 2nd |
| Jiles Freeman | Attack | 2nd | |
| John Ruppersberger | CenterPoint | 3rd | |
| Bill Nuttle | Defense | HM | |
| Charles Herbert | Midfield | HM | |
| Henry Lowery | Attack | HM | |
| 1949 | Patrick Walker | Midfield | 2nd |
| Charles Herbert | Midfield | 3rd | |
| Henry Lowery | Attack | 3rd | |
| Blair Hall | Attack | HM | |
| Louis Phipps | Midfield | HM | |
| 1950 | Charles Herbert | Midfield | 2nd |
| Charles Murphy | Defense | 3rd | |
| William Larash | Goal | HM | |
| Patrick Walker | Midfield | HM | |
| Blair Hall | Midfield | HM | |
| Henry Lowery | Attack | HM | |
| 1951 | William Hubbell | Defense | 1st |
| Elmer Wingate | Defense | 2nd | |
| William Larash | Goal | 3rd | |
| Blair Hall | Midfield | 3rd | |
| Patrick Walker | Midfield | HM | |
| Ted Gournaris | Midfield | HM | |
| Daniel Bonthren | Midfield | HM | |
| Robert Mahan | Attack | HM | |
| 1952 | William Larash | Goal | 1st |
| William Hubbell | Defense | 1st | |
| Tom Lillis | Midfield | HM | |
| 1953 | Rennie Smith | Attack | 2nd |
| Robert Morgan | Defense | 2nd | |
| Charles Wicker | Attack | HM | |
| Dwight Hawksworth | Defense | HM | |
| 1954 | George Corrigan | Attack | 1st |
| Rennie Smith | Attack | 2nd | |
| Charles Wicker | Attack | 3rd | |
| Ben Goertemiller | Midfield | HM | |
| Richard Corrigan | Defense | HM | |
| 1955 | Charles Wicker | Attack | 1st |
| James Keating | Midfield | 1st | |
| John Simmons | Defense | 1st | |
| Rennie Smith | Attack | 2nd | |
| James Kappler | Goal | 2nd | |
| George Corrigan | Attack | HM | |
| Ben Goertemiller | Midfield | HM | |
| Bud Waesche | Midfield | HM | |
| William Spies | Defense | HM | |
| 1956 | Charles Wicker | Attack | 1st |
| James Keating | Midfield | 1st | |
| John Simmons | Defense | 1st | |
| James Kappler | Goal | 1st | |
| Bud Waesche | Midfield | 3rd | |
| Jim Strott | Attack | HM | |
| Dick McNicholas | Midfield | HM | |
| Tamburello | Midfield | HM | |
| John Rehme | Defense | HM | |
| 1957 | Ernie Betz | Midfield | 1st |
| James Kappler | Goal | 1st | |
| Richard Britt | Attack | 2nd | |
| Theodore Kyte | Defense | 2nd | |
| Leroy Skinner | Midfield | HM | |
| Stuart Carlisle | Midfield | HM | |
| Ronald Scheydt | Defense | HM | |
| 1958 | Richard Corrigan | Attack | 1st |
| Ernest Betz | Midfield | 1st | |
| Dick Szlasa | Defense | 2nd | |
| Leroy Skinner | Midfield | 3rd | |
| Roger Goss | Attack | HM | |
| Stuart Carlisle | Midfield | HM | |
| 1959 | Robert Schwartzberg | Defense | 1st |
| Roger Goss | Attack | 2nd | |
| Abrham Tiedeman | Midfield | 3rd | |
| James Keating | Attack | HM | |
| Jerry Thelen | Midfield | HM | |
| Bud Waeshe | Midfield | HM | |
| Fred Kern | Defense | HM | |
| 1960 | Roger Goss | Attack | 2nd |
| Jerry Thelen | Midfield | 3rd | |
| Robert Schwartzberg | Defense | 3rd | |
| Clayton Beardmore | Midfield | HM | |
| 1961 | Clayton Beardmore | Midfield | 1st |
| Fritz Waidner | Attack | 2nd | |
| Gene Rechner | Defense | 3rd | |
| Bob Lemken | Midfield | HM | |
| 1962 | Clayton Beardmore | Midfield | 1st |
| Raymond Altman | Attack | 2nd | |
| Bob Lemken | Midfield | 2nd | |
| 1963 | Ray Altman | Attack | 1st |
| Bill Pettit | Attack | 2nd | |
| Larry Levitt | Midfield | HM | |
| Bob Scheid | Midfield | HM | |
| 1964 | Fred Betz | Midfield | 1st |
| Bill Pettit | Attack | 2nd | |
| Bob Scheid | Midfield | HM | |
| Bill Buck | Defense | HM | |
| John Schofield | Goal | HM | |
| 1965 | John Kenworthy | Midfield | 1st |
| John Schofield | Goal | 1st | |
| John Heim | Attack | 3rd | |
| Bill Buck | Defense | HM | |
| 1966 | John Heim | Attack | 1st |
| Al Pastrana | Defense | 1st | |
| Bob Newkirk | Midfield | 2nd | |
| Alan Lowe | Attack | HM | |
| 1967 | John Heim | Attack | 1st |
| Bruce Hinkle | Midfield | 1st | |
| Alan Lowe | Attack | 2nd | |
| Steve Pfeiffer | Midfield | 2nd | |
| Steven LaVaute | Attack | 3rd | |
| Bill Sbarra | Defense | 3rd | |
| Doug Carter | Midfield | HM | |
| Charles Leimbach | Midfield | HM | |
| Mike Badger | Defense | HM | |
| Norman VanderSchuyt | Goal | HM | |
| 1968 | Stehen Pfeiffer | Midfield | 1st |
| Douglas Carter | Attack | 2nd | |
| Steve LaVaute | Attack | 2nd | |
| Charles Leimbach | Midfield | 2nd | |
| Hugh Mallon | Defense | 2nd | |
| Norman VanderSchuyt | Goal | 2nd | |
| Walter Pettit | Midfield | HM | |
| Bruce Hinkle | Midfield | HM | |
| 1969 | Norman VanderSchuyt | Goal | 2nd |
| Thomas McClenahan | Defense | 2nd | |
| Bruce Piccirillo | Midfield | 3rd | |
| Reed Kaestner | Attack | HM | |
| 1970 | Reed Kaestner | Midfield | 2nd |
| John Kaestner | Attack | 2nd | |
| Thomas McClenahan | Defense | 3rd | |
| Doug Carter | Midfield | HM | |
| 1971 | Tom Cleaver | Attack | 2nd |
| Ira Hochstadt | Defense | 3rd | |
| John Kaestner | Attack | 3rd | |
| Bill Reilly | Goal | HM | |
| Dan Furman | Midfield | HM | |
| 1972 | Doug Scheiber | Midfield | 1st |
| John Kaestner | Attack | 1st | |
| Bill Reilly | Goal | 2nd | |
| Mike Thearle | Defense | 2nd | |
| Gary Besosa | Midfield | 3rd | |
| Kevin Rogers | Midfield | HM | |
| Dave Dempsey | Attack | HM | |
| 1973 | Mike Thearle | Defense | 1st |
| Doug Schreiber | Midfield | 1st | |
| Frank Urso | Midfield | 1st | |
| Pat O'Meally | Attack | 1st | |
| Bill O'Donnell | Goal | 2nd | |
| Rick Avena | Defense | 2nd | |
| Doug Radebaugh | Midfield | 2nd | |
| Gary Besosa | Midfield | 2nd | |
| Ed Mullen | Attack | 2nd | |
| Ed Glatzel | Defense | 3rd | |
| Larry Hubbard | Midfield | HM | |
| Brooks Sleeper | Midfield | HM | |
| 1974 | Mike Farrell | Defense | 1st |
| Frank Urso | Midfield | 1st | |
| Doug Radebaugh | Midfield | 2nd | |
| Roger Tuck | Midfield | 3rd | |
| Ed Mullen | Attack | 3rd | |
| Art Seekamp | Defense | HM | |
| Pat O'Meally | Attack | HM | |
| 1975 | Mike Farrell | Defense | 1st |
| Frank Urso | Midfield | 1st | |
| Doug Radebaugh | Midfield | 1st | |
| Mark Bethmann | Defense | 3rd | |
| Roger Tuck | Attack | 3rd | |
| Gary Niels | Goal | HM | |
| Bert Casewell | Attack | HM | |
| 1976 | Ed Mullen | Attack | 1st |
| Frank Urso | Midfield | 1st | |
| Roger Tuck | Midfield | 1st | |
| Mike Farrell | Defense | 1st | |
| Bob Ott | Midfield | 3rd | |
| Mark Bethmann | Defense | 3rd | |
| Jake Reed | Goal | HM | |
| Mike Hynes | Attack | HM | |
| 1977 | Mike Hynes | Attack | 2nd |
| Peter Worstell | Midfield | 2nd | |
| Jake Reed | Goal | 3rd | |
| Kevin Boland | Midfield | 3rd | |
| Bob Ott | Midfield | 3rd | |
| Randy Ratliff | Defense | 3rd | |
| Bob Boneillo | Attack | HM | |
| Lance Kohler | Midfield | HM | |
| 1978 | Bob Boneillo | Attack | 2nd |
| Peter Worstell | Midfield | 2nd | |
| Rich Shakespeare | Defense | 3rd | |
| Ed Pray | Defense | 3rd | |
| John Lamon | Attack | HM | |
| Bob Ott | Midfield | HM | |
| Barry Mitchell | Midfield | HM | |
| 1979 | Bob Boneillo | Attack | 1st |
| Barry Mitchell | Midfield | 1st | |
| John Lamon | Attack | 2nd | |
| Bob Ott | Midfield | 2nd | |
| Ed Pray | Defense | 3rd | |
| Ron Martinellp | Midfield | HM | |
| Randy Ratliff | Defense | HM | |
| Bryant Waters | Goal | HM | |
| 1980 | Peter Worstell | Midfield | 1st |
| Bob Boneillo | Attack | 3rd | |
| Don Sadler | Defense | HM | |
| 1981 | Peter Worstell | Attack | 2nd |
| Ron Martinello | Attack | HM | |
| Klay Johnson | Midfield | HM | |
| Don Sadler | Defense | HM | |
| 1982 | Jim Wilkerson | Attack | 1st |
| Don Sadler | Midfield | 2nd | |
| 1983 | Jim Wilkerson | Attack | 1st |
| Kevin Sullivan | Midfield | 3rd | |
| Mark Wheeler | Defense | 3rd | |
| Jack Francis | Midfield | HM | |
| Curtis Roundtree | Defense | HM | |
| 1984 | Chris O'Brien | Midfield | 3rd |
| Dan Tracy | Defense | HM | |
| 1985 | Dan Tracy | Defense | 3rd |
| Brian Willard | Attack | HM | |
| 1986 | Tom Worstell | Midfield | 1st |
| Brian Willard | Midfield | 3rd | |
| Brian Jackson | Defense | 3rd | |
| Dan Tracy | Defense | HM | |
| 1987 | Tom Worstell | Midfield | 1st |
| Brian Jackson | Defense | 1st | |
| Jim Beardmore | Goal | 1st | |
| Mike Mosko | Attack | 2nd | |
| Brian Willard | Midfield | 2nd | |
| Brendan Hanley | Attack | HM | |
| Kirk Thurston | Attack | HM | |
| 1988 | Tom Worstell | Midfield | 2nd |
| Phil Willard | Midfield | 3rd | |
| Dan Coughlan | Defense | 3rd | |
| Brendan Hanley | Attack | HM | |
| 1989 | Phil Willard | Midfield | 1st |
| Bill Ralph | Defense | 1st | |
| Mark Douglas | Attack | HM | |
| Jeff McNeil | Defense | HM | |
| 1990 | Bill Ralph | Defense | 2nd |
| Mark Douglas | Midfield | HM | |
| 1991 | Mark Douglas | Attack | 1st |
| Brian Burlace | Defense | 2nd | |
| Rob Wurzburger | Attack | HM | |
| 1992 | Brian Burlace | Defense | 1st |
| Chris Dail | Attack | HM | |
| Dan Reading | Midfield | HM | |
| Steve Kavovit | Goal | HM | |
| 1993 | Bob Huggins | Midfield | 3rd |
| Steve Hayes | Defense | HM | |
| Dan Robbins | Defense | HM | |
| 1994 | Kip Fulks | Midfield | HM |
| Dan Robbins | Midfield | HM | |
| Dan Radebaugh | Defense | HM | |
| 1995 | Dan Radebaugh | Defense | 1st |
| Brian Dougherty | Goal | 1st | |
| Kip Fulks | Midfield | 2nd | |
| Rob Chomo | Attack | 3rd | |
| Greg Nelin | Midfield | HM | |
| 1996 | Brian Dougherty | Goal | 1st |
| Todd Evans | Midfield | 2nd | |
| Dave LaChapelle | Defense | 3rd | |
| Matt Hahn | Attack | HM | |
| Andrew Whipple | Attack | HM | |
| 1997 | David LaChapelle | Defense | 2nd |
| Matt Hahn | Attack | HM | |
| Scott Hochstadt | Attack | HM | |
| Andrew Whipple | Attack | HM | |
| Todd Evans | Midfield | HM | |
| 1998 | Scott Hochstadt | Attack | 2nd |
| Brian Zeller | Midfield | 2nd | |
| Kevin Healy | Goal | 2nd | |
| Matt Hahn | Attack | 3rd | |
| Andrew Whipple | Attack | 3rd | |
| Frank Radin | Midfield | 3rd | |
| Brian Reese | Midfield | HM | |
| Casey Connor | Defense | HM | |
| Chris Lamy | Defense | HM | |
| 1999 | Chris Lamy | Defense | 2nd |
| Casey Connor | Defense | HM | |
| Scott Hochstadt | Attack | HM | |
| 2000 | Casey Conner | Defense | 2nd |
| Chris Malone | Midfield | 3rd | |
| 2001 | Pat McGinnis | Goalie | 1st |
| Andrew Combs | Attack | 2nd | |
| Michael Howley | Defense | 2nd | |
| Chris Malone | Midfield | HM | |
| Mike Mollot | Attack | HM | |
| 2002 | Michael Howley | Defense | 2nd |
| Mike Mollot | Midfield | 2nd | |
| Chris Passavia | Defense | 3rd | |
| Dan LaMonica | Attack | HM | |
| Danny McCormick | Goalie | HM | |
| Nate Watkins | Midfield | HM | |
| 2003 | Michael Howley | Defense | 1st |
| Chris Passavia | Defense | 2nd | |
| Danny McCormick | Goalie | 3rd | |
| Mike Mollot | Midfield | 3rd | |
| Ryan Moran | Midfield | 3rd | |
| Lee Zink | Defense | 3rd | |
| Brett Harper | Def.Midfield | HM | |
| Joe Walters | Attack | HM | |
| 2004 | Joe Walters | Attack | 1st |
| Chris Passavia | Defense | 1st | |
| Lee Zink | Defense | 1st | |
| Paul Gillette | Midfield | 3rd | |
| Bill McGlone | Midfield | 3rd | |
| Brendan Healy | Midfield | HM | |
| Dave Wagner | Defense | HM | |
| Tim McGinnis | Goalie | HM | |
| 2005 | Bill McGlone | Midfield | 1st |
| Joe Walters | Attack | 2nd | |
| Steve Whittenberg | Defense | 3rd | |
| Brendan Healy | Midfield | HM | |
| Ray Megill | Defense | HM | |
| Harry Alford | Goalie | HM | |
| 2006 | Joe Walters | Attack | 1st |
| Bill McGlone | Midfield | 1st | |
| Steve Whittenberg | Defense | 2nd | |
| Ray Megill | Defense | 3rd | |
| Xander Ritz | Attack | HM | |
| Brendan Healy | Midfield | HM | |
| Harry Alford | Goalie | HM | |
| 2007 | Steve Whittenberg | Defense | 2nd |
| Ray Megill | Defense | 2nd | |
| Dan Groot | Midfield | 3rd | |
| Michael Phipps | Attack | HM | |
| 2008 | Joe Cinosky | Defense | 2nd |
| Brian Farrell | Defense | HM | |
| Jeff Reynolds | Midfield | HM | |
| 2009 | Ryan Young | Attack | 2nd |
| Max Schmidt | Defense | 3rd | |
| Grant Catalino | Attack | HM | |
| Dan Groot | Midfield | HM | |
| 2010 | Brian Farrell | Defense | 2nd |
| Grant Catalino | Attack | 3rd | |
| Brett Schmidt | Defense | 3rd | |
| Brian Phipps | Goalie | HM | |
| Max Schmidt | Defense | HM | |
| Ryan Young | Attack | HM | |
| 2011 | Brian Farrell | LSM | 2nd |
| Brett Schmidt | Defense | 2nd | |
| Joe Cummings | Midfield | 3rd | |
| Ryan Young | Attack | 3rd | |
| Grant Catalino | Attack | HM | |
| John Haus | Midfield | HM | |
| Curtis Holmes | Face-Off | HM | |
| Max Schmidt | Defense | HM | |
| 2012 | Jesse Bernhardt | LSM | 2nd |
| Niko Amato | Goalie | HM | |
| Joe Cummings | Attack | HM | |
| John Haus | Midfield | HM | |
| Goran Murray | Defense | HM | |